Is It a Good Idea to Buy Car Insurance Online? – Policygenius (2024)

For decades, the only way to buy car insurance was to sit down with a live agent during traditional work hours, but technology has made it possible to get car insurance with nothing more than a credit card and a smartphone, and to compare quotes with just a few clicks.

Despite the convenience of an online marketplace, lots of people still aren’t comfortable with the idea of buying car insurance on the internet. But online shopping can be an excellent way to find the right auto insurance company for you without the hassle.

Why should I buy insurance online?

Buying car insurance online is a safe, easy, way to get the coverage you need in case of a car accident. Although buying insurance has traditionally happened in an insurance agent’s office, getting auto insurance online means drivers can get a policy no matter where they are, 24/7.

Drivers who are buying a new car or want to add extra types of coverage to their policy, like comprehensive coverage or collision coverage, can purchase whatever coverage they need without ever seeing an agent in person (or even having to talk to someone on the phone).

Buying car insurance online through a marketplace like Policygenius also makes it easy to compare quotes from multiple companies all in one place, and without having to enter the same information over and over again.

Is it safe to purchase insurance online?

Yes, like any purchase, buying car insurance online is perfectly safe as long as you are shopping with a legitimate insurance company or trusted online marketplace. Make sure to do your research and check out any website before you make a purchase.

Reading customer reviews, checking with organizations like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), and choosing popular, well known companies can help you feel secure in the knowledge that you’re not going to fall victim to a scam.

How to buy car insurance online

Getting a car insurance quote is generally a simple process, but there are several steps you should take before buying insurance online that will help make the process as smooth and simple as possible.

1. Choose your coverage amounts

Decide ahead of time what type of coverage you need so you can make sure you are comparing apples to apples. Doing a little research ahead of time can help you know how much liability coverage is right for you, whether or not you need full coverage insurance, how much your deductible should be, and whether or not to purchase extras like roadside assistance.

Don’t forget the coverage types, like gap insurance, that you may need if you are financing or leasing your vehicle.

2. Gather your information

To get an accurate quote, you need to have all of the necessary information available. Expect to share your address, date of birth, driver’s license information, VIN number, annual mileage, and any information about accidents or moving violations you’ve had in the last three years.

3. Compare quotes

After submitting your information you’ll get an auto insurance quote. Whether you are getting quotes directly from an insurance company, through an agent, or through an online marketplace like Policygenius, you should get quotes from multiple companies, including some smaller insurance companies, and compare them to find the best insurance company for your needs.

Comparing car insurance quotes can be tricky; one may be for a six month policy while another is for a full year, or one policy may offer extra coverages, like first accident forgiveness, at no additional cost. Make sure you’re comparing more than just the price, so you can be confident you’re actually choosing the best deal.

4. Choose your company and get your final rate

Once you’ve compared policies, it is time to choose the one that’s right for you. But don’t get too excited yet — once you’ve chosen your policy, the insurance company will review all of your information, including your driving record and, potentially, your credit score.

If the insurance company reviews your information and finds something they weren’t expecting, like an accident or DUI you didn’t disclose, your rate could still change.

5. Print or save your temporary ID cards

Congratulations, you’ve been approved for a car insurance policy! Once everything is official and you’ve made your first payment, your insurance company will either email you temporary ID cards or give you access to them through the company’s mobile app.

Make sure you print or save these cards so you have them in case of an emergency. As soon as your policy goes “in-force,” meaning becomes active, you can start driving knowing you’re protected.

Where to buy car insurance online

Many insurance companies, including GEICO, Farmers, and Progressive, offer customers the option to buy insurance directly through their websites. If you know the insurance company you want to work with sells policies directly to customers, you can go online to their website to purchase a policy — but remember to gather at least three quotes before picking a policy, so you .

There are also online marketplaces — like Policygenius — where you can safely compare quotes from multiple car insurance companies before choosing a policy. Policygenius is an insurance marketplace, which means we offer insurance policies from multiple companies to help you find the best possible coverage for your needs.

What’s the cheapest car insurance online?

Insurance rates are based on a number of factors, which means you could pay a very different rate than someone else, even if you drive the same type of car. Our analysis found that GEICO and State Farm have the lowest average rates, but you will need to get a quote to know how much higher or lower your rate will be than the average.

Drivers who want to save money on their car insurance coverage can use an online marketplace like Policygenius to compare quotes from several different companies.

→ Learn more about the cheapest car insurance companies