Higher vs. Lower Deductible: What's Right for You? (2024)

Looking to insure your home or vehicle? You may have come across important terms like deductible and premium. While the premium is the monthly payment for your insurance plan, the deductible is the amount you will pay out of pocket before your benefits kick in. The higher your deductible, the lower your premium will be, and vice versa.

When deciding which arrangement works best for you, you should consider factors like your budget, your financial situation and, depending on whether you're buying home or car insurance, the area in which you live as well as your driving record. Let's break down high deductible vs. low deductible below.

High Deductible vs. Low Deductible

Insurance companies charge deductibles to give you an incentive to take reasonable precautions and share the responsibility.

Is it better to have a high or low deductible? That all depends on your financial situation. If your finances are robust enough to pay a higher deductible, you'll get the benefit of a lower monthly insurance bill. This could work out in your favor if you don't think you'll need the maximum amount of coverage to which you're entitled.

Choose a lower deductible, however, and pay less money upfront when disaster strikes. While you won't have to dip as far into your nest egg during an emergency, you will need to allocate enough room in your budget to pay a higher insurance bill. With this type of plan, managing your expenses in times of crisis can be much easier as they are more predictable. You may also benefit from higher coverage limits.

Automobile Insurance Considerations

With vehicle insurance, you only pay a deductible towards comprehensive and collision coverage of your own property. That includes theft, vandalism or accidents in which you are at fault. If you damage someone else's property, however, or injure another person, there's no deductible and your insurance policy will cover the entire cost of their repairs or medical care up to the policy limits—that's called liability coverage.

Deductible amounts may vary between $250 and $1,000. Keep in mind that at-fault incidents can stay on your insurance record for several years, which will increase your premiums, so you may not want to file a claim every time. If you're leasing or financing your caror living on a tight budget, a lower deductible can give you more peace of mind. If you have a clean driving record or live in a low-traffic city, getting a high deductible could save you more money in the long run. At the end of the day, the best option is the one that works for your current financial situation.

Homeowners Insurance Considerations

The same inverse relationship applies when it comes to the deductible and the premium amounts for homeowners insurance. As a homeowner, however, your insurance deductible might be a percentage of your total coverage, a specific dollar amount or a hybrid of the two, depending on the type of claim. As with car insurance, you would only pay a deductible if you file a claim. Because hurricanes, earthquakes and flooding often require additional coverage on top of a standard insurance policy, it's best to inquire with your insurance rep for more information as rules may vary from state to state.

How to Calculate Your Insurance Premium

Your monthly premium isn't exclusively determined by the deductible you choose to pay. There are a few other important factors that insurance companies will take into account, including:

  • The extent of your coverage: The more types of coverage you get, the more your insurance premiums will cost.
  • The value of what you're covering. If you're insuring a million-dollar mansion, your premiums will be higher than for a $300,000 bungalow. Similarly, it will cost more to insure a Ferrari than a Toyota.
  • Your personal history. Additional criteria that may be taken into account include your credit score, driving history, past record of claims, lifestyle, residence and employment.
  • Your age. As a predictor of risk and the likelihood that you'll be filing a claim, your age is an important factor in determining how much you will pay. For instance, a younger driver is usually more expensive to insure than a more experienced driver with a spotless record.
  • Actuarial tables. These mathematical algorithms use your personal and demographic information to determine how likely you might be to file a claim and how much it might cost. Insurance companies use these tables to set your premiums accordingly.

Your insurance needs may vary from one year to the next. To find the product that's best for you, consider getting the help of an independent insurance agent. Connect with usto find your next insurance policy.

Higher vs. Lower Deductible: What's Right for You? (2024)

FAQs

Higher vs. Lower Deductible: What's Right for You? ›

High Deductible vs.

Is it better to have higher or lower deductible? ›

If you are generally healthy and don't have pre-existing conditions, a plan with a higher deductible might be a better choice for you. Your monthly premium is lower since you're only visiting the doctor for annual checkups, and you're not in need of frequent health care services.

Is it better to have a $500 deductible or $1000? ›

If you're more likely to get into an accident, you won't want to pay out a higher deductible. However, if you're generally a safer driver, your car insurance premiums will be lower with a $1,000 deductible.

What is the main disadvantage of choosing a high deductible? ›

The main drawback to choosing an HDHP is having potentially high out-of-pocket expenses when you receive covered services during the year.

Why would an insured person choose to pay a higher deductible? ›

Policies with lower deductibles typically have higher premiums, meaning you'll pay more each month for your insurance coverage. However, if you have a higher deductible, you may be able to save money on your premiums but may be responsible for paying more out of pocket if you need to file a claim.

Is a 5000 deductible high for health insurance? ›

For families, the deductible has to be at least $2,700, with a $13,500 max out-of-pocket. Many high deductible plans actually have a much higher deductible ($5,000-$7,000).

What are the pros and cons of having a high deductible? ›

Yes, HDHPs keep your monthly payments low. But there are some downsides you should consider, including: Large medical expenses: Since HDHPs generally only cover preventive care, an accident or emergency could result in very high out-of-pocket costs.

What is a good deductible amount? ›

Before you choose a deductible, most insurance professionals recommend you figure out what you can afford to pay if your car is damaged in an accident. If your budget allows for a maximum out-of-pocket expense of $500, you probably should not choose a deductible higher than $500.

Does a higher deductible lower your car insurance premium? ›

The higher a deductible, the lower the annual, biannual or monthly insurance premiums may be because the consumer is assuming a portion of the total cost of a claim.

What is a good deductible for comprehensive and collision? ›

Both collision and comprehensive insurance generally have a car insurance deductible. Common deductibles are $250, $500, $1,000 and higher. So, if you get into an accident and your vehicle has $2,000 worth of damage and your deductible is $500, the insurance company would pay $1,500 for the claim.

Is PPO or high deductible better? ›

If you know you go to the doctor often, a PPO might make more sense. If you only see a doctor for emergencies, an HDHP might be cheaper. It's worth noting that both HDHPs and PPOs also have copays, or coinsurance, in addition to premiums and deductibles.

Who should not use a high-deductible health plan? ›

Namely, you're responsible for paying a larger portion of your healthcare expenses out of pocket. This can be a significant financial burden for those with a lot of medical expenses and could lead to financial strain. HDHPs may not be the best choice for those with chronic or frequent medical needs.

Why would someone choose a high deductible plan? ›

If you're in good health, rarely need prescription drugs, and don't expect to incur significant medical expenses in the coming year, you might consider an HDHP. In trade for lower premiums, HDHPs require you to meet your deductible before you get any coverage for treatment other than preventive care.

Should I choose a higher or lower deductible? ›

Key takeaways. Low deductibles are best when an illness or injury requires extensive medical care. High-deductible plans offer more manageable premiums and access to HSAs. HSAs offer a trio of tax benefits and can be a source of retirement income.

Do copays count towards deductible? ›

Copays do not count toward your deductible. This means that once you reach your deductible, you will still have copays. Your copays end only when you have reached your out-of-pocket maximum.

Should I pay the deductible if not at fault? ›

It depends on your insurance policy. Some insurance policies require you to pay your deductible even if you are not at fault, while others do not. Reviewing your policy or speaking with your insurance agent to understand your coverage is important.

Does a higher deductible make insurance cheaper? ›

Yes! If you're looking to save money on car insurance, raising your auto insurance deductible may lower your monthly premium payment, but there are some things to consider before making the switch.

What does it mean if I have a $500 deductible health insurance? ›

Deductible: The amount you must pay out of your own pocket before your insurance company will start paying for services. (Example: If you have a $500 deductible per year, and each doctor's visit costs you $100, your insurance may not kick in until you've been to the doctor five times.)

Which is better, high deductible or PPO? ›

In general, HDHPs are better suited for people who are young, single, healthy, or wealthy. PPO plans tend to be better options for people who are older, have a family, or have chronic medical conditions.

Is it better to have a copay or deductible? ›

Deductibles are cumulative annual amounts. While copays are fixed amounts paid per service. Additionally, copays are usually a predictable fixed cost, whereas deductibles can lead to more variable out-of-pocket expenses depending on the healthcare services used.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Domingo Moore

Last Updated:

Views: 5580

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Domingo Moore

Birthday: 1997-05-20

Address: 6485 Kohler Route, Antonioton, VT 77375-0299

Phone: +3213869077934

Job: Sales Analyst

Hobby: Kayaking, Roller skating, Cabaret, Rugby, Homebrewing, Creative writing, amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Domingo Moore, I am a attractive, gorgeous, funny, jolly, spotless, nice, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.